5 touchdowns Jim Shaughnessy, 1964, vs. Warren 4 touchdowns Kevin Kresinski, 1999, vs. Punxsutawney Eric McDay, 1995, vs. Bradford Eric McDay, 1995, vs. Meadville Eric McDay, 1995, vs. Slippery Rock Jim Shaughnessy, 1964, vs. Corry Paul Magee, 1936, vs. Girard Joe Szafran, 1934, vs. Warren Pete Bell, 1933, vs. Titusville * Bill Lilly, 1931, vs. Titusville Johnny Waitkus, 1931, vs. Franklin Bob Begley, 1920, vs. Franklin * Jack Cleaves, 1916, vs. Franklin Howard Alexander, 1916, vs. DuBois * Also threw for two touchdowns. 3 touchdowns Dante Jones, 2006, vs. East Dante Jones, 2005, vs. Titusville Ryan Heasley, 2005, vs. Warren Brian Hahn, 2004, vs. Corry Brian Hahn, 2004, vs. Erie Central Brian Hahn, 2004, vs. Warren Corey Schwab, 2003, vs. DuBois Jamail Jackson, 2003, vs. Meadville Jamail Jackson, 2003, vs. Central Corey Schwab, 2003, vs. Erie East Corey Schwab, 2002, vs. DuBois Matt Siembida, 2000, vs. Strong Vincent Matt Siembida, 2000, vs. Warren Adam Best, 1999, vs. Strong Vincent Kevin Kresinski, 1999, vs. Meadville Kevin Kresinski, 1999, vs. Franklin Kevin Kresinski, 1998, vs. General McLane Tate Osterman, 1997, vs. Erie East Bert McClellan, 1997, vs. Strong Vincent Tate Osterman, 1997, vs. Franklin Eric McDay, 1995, vs. DuBois Jeremy Kase, 1994, vs. Grove City Mike Stephens, 1991, vs. Mercyhurst Brendan Brown, 1991, vs. Sharon Kennedy Christian Mike Stephens, 1991, vs. Lakeview Bill Miller, 1988, vs. Grove City Bill Miller, 1988, vs. Kennedy Christian Chris Conway, 1985, vs. Grove City Mike Jolley, 1985, vs. Warren Chris Conway, 1985, vs. Hickory Mike Jolley, 1985, vs. Hickory Gary Frantz, 1975, vs. Tirusville Ted Kaufman, 1971, vs. Warren Frank Hajduk, 1968, vs. Erie Tech Doug Williams, 1967, vs. Erie Tech Bruce Barr, 1966, vs. Meadville Dave Straub, 1965, vs. Corry Jim Shaughnessy, 1964, vs. Titusville Jim Shaughnessy, 1964, vs. Hickory John Downing, 1963, vs. Hickory Jan DeLong, 1957, vs. Warren Bobby McFadden, 1952, vs. Titusville Bobby McFadden, 1952, vs. Franklin Ken Pleger, 1952, vs. Warren Al Colvenbach, 1951, vs. North East Bobby Hall, 1943, vs. Meadville Ed Klosinski, 1937, vs. Youngsville Paul Mitcham, 1937, vs. Franklin Paul Magee, 1936, vs. Warren * Bill Lilly, 1930, vs. Titusville Johnny Waitkus, 1930, vs. Sharon Harley Johnston, 1929, vs. Union City Frank "Bruv" O'Day, 1927, vs. Warren St. Joseph Bob Moran, 1926, vs. Meadville Ray Vaughn, 1924, vs. Erie Academy Ray Vaughn, 1924, vs. Franklin (First game) Ray Vaughn, 1924, vs. Franklin (Second game) Hugh "Spood" Olmes, 1921, vs. Pittsburgh Westinghouse Harold Peterson, 1920, vs. Titusville George Chacona, 1919, vs. Kane Jack Cleaves, 1915, vs. Rouseville * Lilly also threw for two touchdowns in that game.